$18,000
Available: Right Now
Listed: 24/04/2024
Town of Otsego, NY
Fly Creek Estate - new listing 2024 - This large house was once the site of the Fly Creek Hotel, a stop on the old stagecoach route, and dates back to the late 1880s. Recently renovated and updated, this home is great for a large group. The 1s...
$60,000
Available: Right Now
Listed: 25/04/2024
Town of Otsego, NY
3 minutes to Cooperstown Dreams Park (CDP). We are NOT on the busy road ofCDP. --We are on 15 beautiful, peaceful, private acres.21 minutes to Cooperstown All Star Village. Easy drive. 13 miles are onNY-205/23 (ASV is onNY-205/23.)Note: Renta...
$5,700
Available: Right Now
Listed: 22/04/2024
Town of Otsego, NY
Wheelhouse Studio - This delightful studio apartment enjoys awesome views of the Fly Creek Valley. This home is nestled in the picturesque countryside of Otsego County, three miles outside of Cooperstown. French doors open from the sitting area out t...
$21,240
Available: Right Now
Listed: 22/04/2024
Town of Otsego, NY
Enjoy this beautifully decorated4BR, 2.5bath country home in the quaint village of Fly Creek. Just 3.2 scenic miles to downtown Cooperstown and a short 10 minute drive to Dreams Park. This gorgeous home is fully stocked with linens, pots, pans, d...
$12,960
Available: Right Now
Listed: 26/04/2024
Town of Otsego, NY
A Mountain View Manor House is a three bedroom two full bathroom contemporary home with a loft sleeping area which can be used as a fourth bedroom. With its 22 foot high ceilings the home is very light and airy. Skylights in the living room and upsta...
$9,450
Available: Right Now
Listed: 22/04/2024
Town of Otsego, NY
When visiting Cooperstown you won't find anything more comfortable and cozy than The Bissell House. The Bissell House is where the quaintness of the country meets modern living. Located in the heart of Fly Creek, a hamlet of Cooperstown, this home is...
$29,970
Available: Right Now
Listed: 23/04/2024
Town of Otsego, NY
We are an easy 10 minute drive toCDP, 6minute to Cooperstown Village, and a 28 minute to ASV. Voted as "The #1 Rental in Cooperstown Area". We work hard for it.You and your guests are the only ones on the 15 acre property. This is not shared ...
$69,720
Available: Right Now
Listed: 26/04/2024
Town of Otsego, NY
The Estate at Fly Creek is a destination... and a journey. From the windy road in, over rolling hills with rustic red barns, past wide open pastures of gorgeous horses... to the drive up Bedbug Hill where towering oak, elm and maple trees sway overhe...
$8,070
Available: Right Now
Listed: 22/04/2024
Town of Otsego, NY
Enjoy this beautifully decorated first floor private apartment in The Pottery House which is located in the quaint village of Fly Creek. Just 3.2 scenic miles to downtown Cooperstown and a short 10 minute drive to Dreams Park. This spacious 2BR, ...
$11,850
Available: Right Now
Listed: 26/04/2024
Town of Otsego, NY
Creekside Cottage is conveniently located in Fly Creek, NY only 6 minutes (3 miles) to the village of Cooperstown, 14 minutes (6 miles) to Cooperstown Dreams Park, 26 minutes (20 miles) to AllStar Village.Undoubtedly you will spend most of your t...
$5,100
Available: Right Now
Listed: 22/04/2024
Town of Otsego, NY
Beautifully updated, spacious, private carriage house in historical Fly Creek, NY. Located within half a mile to the Fly Creek Cider Mill and 4.5 miles to the center of Cooperstown, and just a quick 7.5 miles to the Cooperstown Dreams Park.Our cl...
$7,650
Available: Right Now
Listed: 22/04/2024
Town of Otsego, NY
Day House - is a two-story home in a quiet country setting, very convenient to Cooperstown and the Dreams Park. This home is in pristine condition. Choose Day House if you want to enjoy a private rural setting less than a10 minute drive to the D...
$6,600
Available: Right Now
Listed: 26/04/2024
Town of Otsego, NY
* Rent from a local !* This is a charming, late 1800s home in the hamlet of Fly Creek! 4 bedrooms 2 bathrooms, private yard and a dedicated work space! From here you can walk to the Fly Creek General Store for all your basic needs and then...
$5,250
Available: Right Now
Listed: 22/04/2024
Town of Otsego, NY
* Rent from a local !* Welcome to Oaks Creek Cottage in Fly Creek!!! This adorable 3 bed 2 bath house is RIGHT on Oaks Creek! Go 1 mile down the road to the Fly Creek General Store and grab a fishing pole! Also included is a fire pit, outdoor ...
$5,970
Available: Right Now
Listed: 22/04/2024
Town of Otsego, NY
** Rent from a local !** Welcome to Oaks Creek Manor! This single family home was built in 1880, Oaks Creek is right in the backyard! Come for the Cooperstown attractions,stay for the relaxing creek,comfy beds,private and spacious outdoor spac...
$36,420
Available: Right Now
Listed: 22/04/2024
Town of Otsego, NY
16x30 Heated Salt water PoolPatio with outdoor fireplace2 master bedrooms downstairs Located in the town of Otsego, just a few short miles from both the Baseball Hall of Fame and the Cooperstown Dreams Park. The home offers an open floor ...
$30,600
Available: Right Now
Listed: 24/04/2024
Town of Otsego, NY
Calypso Hill is a beautiful, luxurious home right in the heart of Fly Creek. The home has modern features and amenities including a sleek and sophisticated modern kitchen, open concept living room with a large beautiful dining area, work out room, a ...
$25,500
Available: Right Now
Listed: 24/04/2024
Town of Otsego, NY
Hilltop Retreat is a beautiful custom built home in Fly Creek, a hamlet of Cooperstown, NY. Located on a hilltop with 27 acres of beautiful rolling hills and pastures with its own private pond and walking trails. All features of this home are modern ...
$6,750
Available: Right Now
Listed: 22/04/2024
Town of Otsego, NY
1825 Cottage - The original frame of this recently renovated home was post and beam construction, but the whole interior is new. The original beams are exposed, and old building materials have been re-purposed - giving this an upscale mix of vintag...
$6,540
Available: Right Now
Listed: 26/04/2024
Town of Otsego, NY
Small-town charm and serene views await at this Fly Creek vacation rental! This 3-bedroom, 2.5-bathroom home offers a peaceful haven for the whole crew, along with convenient proximity to the area's attractions. Ride the village trolley into Cooperst...
$6,840
Available: Right Now
Listed: 23/04/2024
Town of Otsego, NY
1825 Farmhouse - The frame of the 1825 Farmhouse was built at the same time as the 1825 Cottage (neighboring rental). The original staircase has been retained and refinished, showing the patina and warmth that only aged wood provides.A covered pa...
$6,060
Available: Right Now
Listed: 23/04/2024
Town of Otsego, NY
1825 Barn - Only 10 minutes to the Dreams Park! The original post and beam frame of the 1825 Barn was constructed c 1825. This home is actually 2 very early post and beam frames that were joined together. Your skilled host has built a contemporary ho...