No Photos
4 bedroom House for sale: 44 Saint Marys Road in Shelter Island, New York | Mayfair International
44 Saint Marys Road in Shelter Island

4 bedroom House for sale: 44 Saint Marys Road in Shelter Island, New York | Mayfair International

house for sale
Listed: 10/13/23

44 Saint Marys Road in Shelter Island

Studio Bed:
Save
Price
$ 4,5M

About This House

This meticulously crafted Shelter Island 8.12 +/- acre estate property is currently configured with 3 substantial structures: a 3 bedroom, 4 bath primary residence, a 2-car carriage house with loft apartment, and a 3-stall horse barn with tack room and loft space. This is a rare opportunity to live your equestrian dreams or reimagine this C-Zone property as a sprawling compound with commercial/work options. The property can be subdivided into separate parcels. The pastures, paddocks, and cedar groves make this a true gem for horse enthusiasts, a compound with multiple dwelling options or a gym/yoga, art studio, or light commercial/work spaces. The centerpiece of this remarkable estate is the main residence, a 3,225 +/- af country home featuring 3 ensuite …  Full description

Property Includes

  • PATIO
  • Garage
  • Pool
  • 2 Wood-burning Fireplaces
  • Room For Tennis
  • Parking Garage
  • Parking

Property Manager

Protect Yourself From Rental Scams

While we strive to provide accurate and timely information, it's essential to remain vigilant and do your due diligence when considering rental properties. Make sure to follow expert tips to reduce the risk of fraud when renting a new apartment.

Similar Houses for Sale Nearby

$5,18M

Studio

$5,18M

Available: Right Now

Listed: 30/05/2024

43 Harbor Drive in Sag Harbor

House
Studio
PATIO
Parking
1 Wood-burning Fireplace
Washer/Dryer
Den
Waterfront
Pool
Parking Garage

Welcome to 43 Harbor Drive, located in Sag Harbor's prestigious waterfront community of Bay Point. The fully bulk-headed property is perfectly sited on Sag Harbor Cove and features a 3,300+/- sf modern home with pool and deep-water dock. The home is ...

$4,45M

Studio

$4,45M

Available: Right Now

Listed: 30/05/2024

1739 Millstone Road in Sag Harbor

House
Studio
Garage
Parking Garage
Fitness Room
Parking
Pool
2 Wood-burning Fireplaces

This classic Hamptons residence combines the most preferred traditional and modern design and architectural elements to maximize comfort, convenience, and space. The new Sag Harbor home offers 3,724+/- sf of living space on the first and second floor...

$4,4M

Studio

$4,4M

Available: Right Now

Listed: 30/05/2024

6 Ocean View Parkway in North Sea

House
Studio
PATIO
Den
Eat-in Kitchen
Parking Garage
1 Wood-burning Fireplace
Room For Tennis
Garage
Parking
Pool

Secluded and amenity-filled, this Southampton property features an expansive 6000+/- sf of immaculate interior living space across 3 stories and multiple indoor and outdoor entertaining areas. This home has it all, from sprawling lush grounds to a lu...

$4M

Available: Right Now

Listed: 27/05/2024

7 King Street, Village of East Hampton, NY 11937, USA

House
Studio

This new custom designed2514 SF, 4Bed 4 Bath home just broke ground and features a unique pre-existing1800 SFbarn with 18 FT ceilings. It can accommodate 7 cars or be converted into either a personal gallery or working art studio. The heated gunite p...

$4,4M

Studio

$4,4M

Available: Right Now

Listed: 30/05/2024

25 Alewive Brook Road in East Hampton

House
Studio
Fitness Room
Garage
2 Wood-burning Fireplaces
Parking Garage
Pool
Washer/Dryer
PATIO
Den
Parking

Nestled near Three Mile Harbor and Cedar Point Park, and conveniently situated just 15 minutes from the villages of East Hampton and Sag Harbor, this remarkable 1.7+/- acre newly reconstructed property envisioned by Domicile & Co., offers the ideal H...

$4,4M

Studio

$4,4M

Available: Right Now

Listed: 30/05/2024

5 Guernsey Lane in East Hampton

House
Studio
Washer/Dryer
Garage
Parking
Den
6 Wood-burning Fireplaces
Fitness Room
PATIO
Pool
Parking Garage

Will be Finished spring 2024 New open-concept construction in the desired location of Lion Head Beach. Private beach access approx. 150 yards down the road. Water view from the upper deck. Five bedrooms, five and a half baths including lower l...

Shelter Island Housing & Living

Household Income

Median household income: $110,148
Number of households: 629
The average household income in Shelter Island, NY grew from $76,967 to $110,148 in the past year. This data is an estimate based upon 629 households in Shelter Island, NY.
The chart below presents how household income is distributed in Shelter Island, NY in comparison to the revenue allocation amid households nationally.

Property Taxes

Average range: $3k+
One of the most important aspects for property owners is the amount of property taxes. This graph shows distribution of property taxes in Shelter Island, NY compared to median property taxes around the country. The prevalent amount of property taxes in Shelter Island, NY equals $3k+ , which is more than the national average.