No Photos
Image 1 - 4 Bayview Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, NY 11965, USA - House for sale
Image 2 - 4 Bayview Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, NY 11965, USA - House for sale
Image 3 - 4 Bayview Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, NY 11965, USA - House for sale
Image 4 - 4 Bayview Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, NY 11965, USA - House for sale
Image 5 - 4 Bayview Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, NY 11965, USA - House for sale
Image 6 - 4 Bayview Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, NY 11965, USA - House for sale
Image 7 - 4 Bayview Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, NY 11965, USA - House for sale
Image 8 - 4 Bayview Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, NY 11965, USA - House for sale
Image 9 - 4 Bayview Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, NY 11965, USA - House for sale
Home For Sale In Shelter Island, New York
4 Bayview Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, NY 11965, USA

Home For Sale In Shelter Island, New York

house for sale
Listed: 02/07/24

4 Bayview Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, NY 11965, USA

6 Bed:
5.5 Bath:
6,098 Sq Ft Living Area:
Save
Price
$ 3,75M

About This House

Located in the Historic Shelter Island Heights, the property was designed for entertaining, features six bedrooms, five and a half bathrooms, gunite pool, expansive newly installed mahogany decks on main house and guest house, fully finished lower level is walk out to pool and back yard. Main house has multiple sitting areas throughout the home. There is a detached two car garage with radiant heat flooring, and an open concept apartment with full bathroom, laundry, and private deck. Property is landscaped for privacy and has large parking area

Protect Yourself From Rental Scams

While we strive to provide accurate and timely information, it's essential to remain vigilant and do your due diligence when considering rental properties. Make sure to follow expert tips to reduce the risk of fraud when renting a new apartment.

Similar Houses for Sale Nearby

$3,39M

Available: Right Now

Listed: 31/05/2024

4 Gazon Road, Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, NY 11964, USA

House
6
4.5
4,100 Sq Ft

Come see this designer renovated 6 bedroom, 4.5 bath colonial home. It includes a legal accessory apartment over the detached 2 car garage. You will love relaxing on your dock on the private waterfront lot at the end of the short private road from th...

$3,4M

6
5.5
6,250 Sq Ft

$3,4M

Available: Right Now

Listed: 31/05/2024

1750 Mount Beulah Avenue, Southold, NY 11971, USA

House
6
5.5
6,250 Sq Ft

Introducing one of the North Fork's most iconic properties, seamlessly blending historical grandeur with contemporary living. Originally constructed circa 1915 to house stables and additional living quarters for the former 40-acre waterfront Cosden e...

$3,4M

6
6
5,000 Sq Ft

$3,4M

Available: Right Now

Listed: 27/05/2024

22 Dumar Drive, Noyack, Suffolk County, NY 11963, USA

House
6
6
5,000 Sq Ft

This stunningly renovated modern with water views, architectural lines, and gorgeous landscaping is a fantastic value. With potential for 6-7 bedrooms above ground (with expanded septic), this is a unique opportunity to live by the water in Sag Harbo...

$3,25M

6
5.5
3,376 Sq Ft

$3,25M

Available: Right Now

Listed: 27/05/2024

8 Valley Road, Noyack, Suffolk County, NY 11963, USA

House
6
5.5
3,376 Sq Ft

Experience the epitome of luxury living in the highly sought-after Sag Harbor with this newly constructed, light-filled home boasting 6 bedrooms and 5.5 bathrooms. Impeccably designed, the residence features open living, dining, and kitchen areas, a ...

$3,9M

6
5.5
6,000 Sq Ft

$3,9M

Available: Right Now

Listed: 29/05/2024

129 Clay Pit Road, Noyack, Suffolk County, NY 11963, USA

House
6
5.5
6,000 Sq Ft

NEW Pre-construction offering! Situated near Sag Harbor Village, this sprawling 2-acre haven offers over6, 000sq. ft. of opulent living space across three levels, boasting 6 ensuite bedrooms and 5.5 bathrooms. Upon arrival, a private 500 ft driveway ...

$3,5M

6
6.5
4,600 Sq Ft

$3,5M

Available: Right Now

Listed: 31/05/2024

222 Northside Drive, Noyack, Suffolk County, NY 11963, USA

House
6
6.5
4,600 Sq Ft

4, 600sqft of sun filled 6 Bedrooms. Welcome to a newly renovated home in the prestigious Northside Hills neighborhood. With six bedrooms and six full and two half baths, two separate entrances and a newly renovated safe room on the third floor, this...

Shelter Island Heights Housing & Living

Household Income

Median household income: $120,787
Number of households: 561
The average household income in Shelter Island Heights, NY declined from $135,063 to $120,787 in the past year. This data is an estimate based upon 561 households in Shelter Island Heights, NY.
The chart below presents how household income is distributed in Shelter Island Heights, NY in comparison to the revenue allocation amid households nationally.

Property Taxes

Average range: $3k+
One of the most important aspects for property owners is the amount of property taxes. This graph shows distribution of property taxes in Shelter Island Heights, NY compared to median property taxes around the country. The prevalent amount of property taxes in Shelter Island Heights, NY equals $3k+ , which is more than the national average.