No Photos
Image 1 - 20 Prospect Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, NY 11965, USA - House for sale
Image 2 - 20 Prospect Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, NY 11965, USA - House for sale
Image 3 - 20 Prospect Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, NY 11965, USA - House for sale
Image 4 - 20 Prospect Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, NY 11965, USA - House for sale
Image 5 - 20 Prospect Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, NY 11965, USA - House for sale
Image 6 - 20 Prospect Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, NY 11965, USA - House for sale
Image 7 - 20 Prospect Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, NY 11965, USA - House for sale
Image 8 - 20 Prospect Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, NY 11965, USA - House for sale
Image 9 - 20 Prospect Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, NY 11965, USA - House for sale
Home For Sale In Shelter Island Heights, New York
20 Prospect Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, NY 11965, USA

Home For Sale In Shelter Island Heights, New York

house for sale
Listed: 03/05/24

20 Prospect Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, NY 11965, USA

7 Bed:
6 Bath:
5,000 Sq Ft Living Area:
Save
Price
$ 5,45M

About This House

Introducing Aquarelle at 20 Prospect Ave, an iconic piece of Shelter Island Heights history. Built in 1883, this distinguished home holds a cherished place among the original residences in this esteemed neighborhood, now classified as a national historic district. Stepping onto Prospect Avenue, once known as Divinity Hill, you'll find yourself transported to a time when Methodist ministers from New York flocked to this area in the late 1800s to worship at the Union Chapel in the Grove. These devout individuals constructed the houses along Divinity Hill, including 20 Prospect Ave. Originally, these homes did not have kitchens, as residents would either gather at the Chequit Inn for communal meals or have their meals delivered by donkey cart. One notable …  Full description

Protect Yourself From Rental Scams

While we strive to provide accurate and timely information, it's essential to remain vigilant and do your due diligence when considering rental properties. Make sure to follow expert tips to reduce the risk of fraud when renting a new apartment.

Similar Houses for Sale Nearby

$6,5M

Available: Right Now

Listed: 27/05/2024

115 Ram Island Drive, Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, NY 11965, USA

House
7
6.5
4,941 Sq Ft

There is nothing like this magnificent water front modern with panoramic views out to CT. The word WOW is an understatement referring to the architectural design which will take your breath away. The entry opens up to an expansive great room. The far...

$5,5M

7
6.5
4,171 Sq Ft

$5,5M

Available: Right Now

Listed: 26/05/2024

24 Ruggs Path, Noyack, Suffolk County, NY 11963, USA

House
7
6.5
4,171 Sq Ft

Presenting one of 2 final custom-crafted residences to be offered at The Preserve, Sag Harbor's newest luxury home community located directly across from Mill Creek Marina and just 3 miles from the historic downtown district. Spanning6, 307sq. ft, th...

$4,98M

7
7.5
6,500 Sq Ft

$4,98M

Available: Right Now

Listed: 27/05/2024

500 Broadwaters Road, Cutchogue, Southold, NY 11935, USA

House
7
7.5
6,500 Sq Ft

Waterfront ! This finely crafted, state-of-the-art, new construction home is perfectly situated on.74 acres. With over 70 feet of waterfront on Broadwaters Cove in coveted Nassau Point, this property boasts a prestigious address. Located near ...

$6M

7
6.5
8,000 Sq Ft

$6M

Available: Right Now

Listed: 28/05/2024

157 Merchants Path, Noyack, East Hampton, NY 11975, USA

House
7
6.5
8,000 Sq Ft

This gorgeous new 8, 000 +/- total sq. ft. home is currently under development on 1.47 very private acres in East Hampton. Designed by McDonough and Conroy, R.A.,and in collaboration with Luxury builder, Hampton Builders, Inc. and Fineo Development G...

$6M

Available: Right Now

Listed: 28/05/2024

136 Middle Line Highway, Water Mill, Suffolk County, NY 11968, USA

House
7
7.5
7,800 Sq Ft

Perfectly sited on 1.41 acres in a Southampton Estate setting this home boasts7800 SF +/- on three levels. The generous interior living spaces, flooded with light, offer an impressive entry with double height ceiling leading to a huge great room with...

$6,49M

Available: Right Now

Listed: 31/05/2024

116 Middle Line Highway, Southampton, North Sea, NY 11968, USA

House
7
7.5

Nestled amidst the verdant beauty of Southampton 116 Middle Line Highway beckons with an allure that transcends mere luxury-it's a testament to refined living. As the automatic entry gate whispers open, a sense of exclusivity envelops you, promising ...

Shelter Island Heights Housing & Living

Household Income

Median household income: $120,787
Number of households: 561
The average household income in Shelter Island Heights, NY declined from $135,063 to $120,787 in the past year. This data is an estimate based upon 561 households in Shelter Island Heights, NY.
The chart below presents how household income is distributed in Shelter Island Heights, NY in comparison to the revenue allocation amid households nationally.

Property Taxes

Average range: $3k+
One of the most important aspects for property owners is the amount of property taxes. This graph shows distribution of property taxes in Shelter Island Heights, NY compared to median property taxes around the country. The prevalent amount of property taxes in Shelter Island Heights, NY equals $3k+ , which is more than the national average.