Home For Rent In Shelter Island, New York

Complete top to bottom renovation just complete, with all new furniture, linens, appliances and more. Close to Sag Harbor in peaceful North Haven, this tasteful 6 bedroom, 6 bathroom newly constructed shingle-style manse on two lush acres offers prim...

Brand new heated gunite saltwater pool!!!!A sparkling clean and modern 6 bedroom, 4 bath waterfront home offering all the luxuries you'll want and more for your North Fork vacation. Private 6 acre property features gorgeous water views, long dock...

Large home available with 6 Bedroom and 5 Full Bathrooms. Sleeps large group. House has Pool, lounge chairs, and out-door shower. Two outdoor table sets, sits 8 people each. House located in Sag harbor, but near Bridgehampton. Fully equipped kitchen,...

Huge private property in desired Sag Harbor with impeccably designed landscaping. This 4,400+/- sq. ft. custom built home offers an oasis with land preserve surrounding most of the property. The home boasts unique custom details, such as exposed recl...

This .95 acre residence is a very special property, featuring park-like grounds with Har-Tru tennis court, pool, Jacuzzi and golf cart! One of the few closest parcels within short distance Sag Harbor Bay beaches, and nearby marinas for fishing and bo...

European elegance meets active waterfront living at the 6-bedroom, 5.5-bath Sunset Bayan expansive, amenity-packed dream home on Noyack Bay with its own private bay beach.Begin your Sag Harbor vacation by uncorking that sweet, first bottle of win...