Home For Rent In Shelter Island, New York

This beautiful Contemporary home has 1.8 acres of rolling green lawn and water views of both Coecles Harbor and Gardiner's Bay. The main floor has a great room with fireplace, vaulted ceilings, dining area and two-story windows that maximize the view...

This soothing beach house is so Zen, you will feel like you are at a spa retreat. Peaceful and perfectly appointed, the backyard features a fabulous lagoon style pool, with a waterfall and hot tub, an amazing outdoor kitchen and bar, bathroom and out...

Great 3-bedroom summer rental in the private, sought-after Sag Harbor waterfront community of North Haven Manor, just a block to the community's pristine bay beach. This beautiful home is the perfect marriage of charm and new chic designer furnishing...

State-of-the-art and eloquently constructed by notable architect Frank Greenwald is this modern gem on Harry's Lane in Sag Harbor. Pull up to a towering wall of glass above the lower-level garage and drop your bags. The proper entry foyer with a powd...

$95, 000July 1st thru Labor Day$15, 000April 1-30th$15, 000May 1-31st$15, 000October 1-31st$15, 000November 1-30th$15, 000December 1-31st$15, 000January 1-31st$15, 000Feburary 1-28th$15, 000March 1-31st Nestled enchantingly in the heart of Sag Harbor...

This is a charming single story rental option in the popular Redwood section of Sag Harbor Village. The updated ranch style home has a sunny and comfortable living area which opens to the dining and bright white kitchen. There are three bedrooms and ...