No Photos
Image 1 - 2 Sylvan Place, Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, NY 11965, USA - House for rent
Image 2 - 2 Sylvan Place, Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, NY 11965, USA - House for rent
Image 3 - 2 Sylvan Place, Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, NY 11965, USA - House for rent
Image 4 - 2 Sylvan Place, Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, NY 11965, USA - House for rent
Image 5 - 2 Sylvan Place, Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, NY 11965, USA - House for rent
Image 6 - 2 Sylvan Place, Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, NY 11965, USA - House for rent
Image 7 - 2 Sylvan Place, Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, NY 11965, USA - House for rent
Image 8 - 2 Sylvan Place, Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, NY 11965, USA - House for rent
Image 9 - 2 Sylvan Place, Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, NY 11965, USA - House for rent
Home For Rent In Shelter Island Heights, New York
2 Sylvan Place, Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, NY 11965, USA
Bed
3.5  Bath
2,623  Sq Ft

Home For Rent In Shelter Island Heights, New York

house for rent
views
Listed: 02/29/24

2 Sylvan Place, Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, NY 11965, USA

5 Bed
3.5 Bath
2,623 Sq Ft
Save
Monthly Price
$ 40,000

About This House

Beautifully restored iconic Shelter Island Heights Victorian with lovely views of Dering Harbor, Chase Creek, rolling green lawns and a small treed park. Situated within convenient proximity to all that Shelter Island Heights offers with shops, restaurants, marina, beach club, ferry and transportation to NYC, this 5 bedroom home has three full and two half baths, including master and guest suites; a living room with central stone fireplace, spacious dining room, chef's kitchen with charming breakfast nook, laundry area, mud room and water view covered wrap porches. There is also a separate garage and driveway for easy parking. A salute to Shelter Island's historical past with every modern amenity. [[Rental Registration # 2023-L-0145]]

Protect Yourself From Rental Scams

While we strive to provide accurate and timely information, it's essential to remain vigilant and do your due diligence when considering rental properties. Make sure to follow expert tips to reduce the risk of fraud when renting a new apartment.

Similar Houses for Rent Nearby

$40,470

5
5
2,300 Sq Ft

$40,470

Available: Right Now

Listed: 04/05/2024

Shelter Island Heights, NY

House
5
5
2,300 Sq Ft
Air Conditioning
Garden
Parking
Pool
Dishwasher
Fireplace
Tv
Phone
Shampoo
Iron/ironing Board

Beautiful turn-of-the century Victorian Summer Beautiful turn of the century home located on Rainbow Park with breathtaking views of Dering Harbor !Large sunny eat- in kitchen with marble floors and countertops with access to veranda and patio to...

$40,000

Available: Right Now

Listed: 03/05/2024

37 Grand Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, Suffolk County, NY 11965, USA

House
5
3.5
2,596 Sq Ft

Rental Registration #2022-S-0002.Since the turn of the century, this Victorian has greeted visitors coming from the North Ferry onto Shelter Island. It has a new life with a full-scale, high end restoration that imbues the best of yesterday with the ...

$39,450

5
7

$39,450

Available: Right Now

Listed: 01/05/2024

Shelter Island, NY

House
5
7
Pool
Air Conditioning
Fireplace
Parking
Bed Sheets Provided
Towels Provided
Toaster
English
Washer
Smoke-free Property

Please note that a reservation for this property needs to be approved before it is confirmed.Shelter Island Manor Luxurious 2-home estate completely secluded on 8 acres ; Professionally manicured gardens & Heated pool ( <...

$47,250

5
3
2,700 Sq Ft

$47,250

Available: Right Now

Listed: 05/05/2024

Town of Southold, NY, 11944

House
5
3
2,700 Sq Ft
Fireplace
Balcony
Parking
Air Conditioning
Garden
Dishwasher
Swimming Nearby
Lobster/crab Pot
Dining Room
Washing Machine And Dryer

Same location I have two 2 cottages that sleep 4 each . See VRBO search bar [Where To] with the ListingID 173361and the ListingID 167288.The centerpiece of this family owned waterfront estate, “The Main House” is a neo-victorian 5-bedroom, 3-bath...

$48,000

5
3

$48,000

Available: Right Now

Listed: 04/05/2024

Town of Southold, NY, 11944

House
5
3
Air Conditioning
Internet
Hair Dryer
Bathtub Or Shower
Shampoo
Washer
Wifi
Iron/ironing Board
Towels Provided
Heater

Bring the whole family to this great place with lots of room for indoor and outdoor activities! Enjoy an entire Greenport home to yourselves. You have access to all rooms on the first and second floors, an enclosed back yard with a partially cove...

$34,080

5
4
3,500 Sq Ft

$34,080

Available: Right Now

Listed: 02/05/2024

Town of Southold, NY, 11944

House
5
4
3,500 Sq Ft
Air Conditioning
Dishwasher
Pool
Fireplace
Parking
Microwave
No Smoking
Crib
Heated Pool
Spices

An outdoor oasis is one element of this extraordinary property. This one of a kind 5 bedroom, 3.5 bath residence is the perfect home to make special memories this season. The perfect rental with one of the most extraordinary pool and garden areas on ...

Custom Offers

Custom Offers

You can negotiate the price for this house on 2 Sylvan Place, Shelter Island Heights.
eSign lease online

eSign Lease

Save time and paper. Sign your lease online and get ready to move to a house in Shelter Island Heights.

Commute Info

Commute Time

The workers of Shelter Island Heights, NY traveled to their offices around 32 minutes lately and drove alone to get there. The rest of the residents worked at home and carpooled.
Average travel time: 38.8 minutes

Commuter Transportation

The most common method of travel for workers in Shelter Island Heights, NY was Drove Alone (76.1%) , followed by those who used Other (14.4%) and those who Carpooled (5.7%).