Home For Rent In Shelter Island, New York

Charming renovated cottage on lovely treed and landscaped half acre not far from the Island Boatyard Marina and both Wades and Crescent Beaches. Surrounded with beautiful trees affording a private country ambience, this immaculate 2 bedroom home with...

Welcome to your dream summer rental in Sag Harbor with 270-degree views of Noyack Bay! This charming cottage-style home boasts 2 bedrooms, 1 full bath, and 900 +/- sq. ft. of living space, all situated on a bright and beachy.32 acre property. This si...

Two Queen Bedrooms and a loft with two twins available in a quaint, clean beach cottage that is conveniently located 2 1/2 blocks from beach, short drive into downtown Sag Harbor. 1/4 mile walk to Trout Pond for fresh-water swimming. Up the street we...

Enjoy a stylish experience at this centrally-located townhome. Right in the heart of downtown Sag Harbor within walking distance to gourmet restaurants and all the shops. This gorgeous new home has 2 bedrooms with en-suite bathrooms, 1 with a Queen b...

Come stay by the bay. The home is close to great bay beaches and a farm stand. Close to Sag Harbor village. Central air. New kitchen. King bed in the primary with tv. Queen bed in the other bedroom. Additional room/office. Great natural light. Peacef...

A great place for a short or long-term vacation, this beautiful, 2-bedroom, 2-bath ranch home is located in a quiet neighborhood just blocks from the beach and a short 5-minute drive or 2-mile bike ride to Sag Harbor Village.The home features an ...